Hersheys Ice Cream vs. The Charmery: Which Baltimore Spot Wins Your Heart?

Jun 08, 2026

Baltimore's Ice Cream Scene

Baltimore is home to a vibrant culinary scene, and when it comes to satisfying a sweet tooth, the city offers a plethora of options. Two names that often come up in discussions about the best ice cream in town are Hershey's Ice Cream and The Charmery. Both have their loyal fans, but how do they truly compare?

ice cream cone

The Legacy of Hershey's Ice Cream

Hershey's Ice Cream boasts a rich history, with roots going back to 1894. Known for its wide array of flavors and creamy texture, Hershey's has become a staple for many Baltimoreans. This brand focuses on traditional flavors while incorporating new and exciting ones to keep customers coming back for more.

Some popular choices at Hershey's include classic vanilla, mint chocolate chip, and the ever-popular cookies and cream. Their commitment to quality ingredients ensures each scoop is a delightful experience.

The Charmery's Unique Flavors

In contrast, The Charmery has carved out a niche with its unique and often quirky flavor combinations. Founded in 2013, this local gem has quickly become a favorite for those seeking something different. The Charmery prides itself on using local ingredients to craft flavors that celebrate Baltimore's culture and community.

From Old Bay Caramel to Maryland Mud, The Charmery's menu is a testament to creativity and local pride. Their rotating selections mean there's always something new to try, making each visit an adventure.

ice cream shop

Atmosphere and Experience

When it comes to atmosphere, Hershey's Ice Cream provides a classic and family-friendly environment. It's a place where you can enjoy a scoop while reminiscing about the past. Their shops are often cozy, with a nostalgic charm that appeals to all ages.

On the other hand, The Charmery offers a vibrant and eclectic ambiance. Each location is decorated with fun, whimsical touches, and the staff's enthusiasm adds to the overall experience. It's the perfect spot for those looking to enjoy a lively ice cream outing.

Price and Accessibility

Price is often a consideration when choosing where to indulge. Hershey's Ice Cream typically offers more traditional pricing, making it accessible for families and larger groups. It's an affordable option for a casual treat.

The Charmery, with its artisanal approach, might be on the pricier side. However, many argue that the unique flavors and quality justify the cost, especially for those looking to explore beyond the ordinary.

ice cream sundae

Final Thoughts: Which Wins Your Heart?

Ultimately, the choice between Hershey's Ice Cream and The Charmery comes down to personal preference. If you favor classic flavors and a nostalgic vibe, Hershey's might be your go-to. However, if you're in the mood for inventive flavors and a lively atmosphere, The Charmery could steal your heart.

Both spots offer something special, making Baltimore a fantastic city for ice cream lovers. Whether you stick with tradition or embrace the new, you’re sure to find a favorite in this charming city.